Would You Call Out Your Child’s Teacher?

Would You Call Out Your Child’s Teacher?

my_words_are_broken_by_fall0nMy daughter came home from school this week with two incidents by two separate teachers on what I’d like to call word abuse. One involves spelling and one is pronunciation.

This is where I don my nerd cap and damn it, I’m going to wear it proudly. I’ve always been a pretty good speller and often as I read my children’s papers and/or homework, I have to control my urges to point out each and every misspelled word. They are growing their vocabulary and I can’t expect them to be perfect spellers right out of the gate. I think the only thing that really help this is just plain ol’ reading. So anyway, onto my story.

Earlier in the week, my 7th grade daughter, we’ll call her A, came home from school asking me how to spell serenade. I told her and she exclaimed, “That’s how I spelled it and my teacher said that was wrong!” I guess they had a spelling bee in class and the word serenade knocked everyone out except one. I asked her how the winner spelled it and she said, no joke, “Screnade.” I asked her to give me the definition the teacher gave, thinking maybe she misheard her. She said blah, blah, blah…something about singing. I asked her about five more times to tell me how the teacher spelled it. Sure as shit, A said “s-c-r-e-n-a-d-e” each and every time. So the girl that totally jacked up the spelling won.

I asked my daughter if anyone questioned the teacher about it and she said they all did. Everyone was metaphorically scratching their heads but the teacher stuck to her illiterate guns.

After she told me this, in my head, I was like, “Are you fucking kidding me?” Screnade? And this is her reading/communications arts teacher!!!

Part 2 of the story…

My daughter came home from school today and began quizzing me on some things she was studying for a social studies test. She was testing her dear old Mom, trying to make me look like an idiot and it was partially working.

She asked me a question about Napoleon Bonaparte, which I had to ask her to say his name again, wondering if I heard her right. She repeated his name, saying it like  ”Na-pole-ee-an Bone-a-party.” I assumed she hadn’t understood the “e” was silent at the end of his last name so I corrected her. Guess what she said?

“Oh, my teacher says ‘Bone-a-party’ all the time.” Awesome. This is her social studies teacher…the one who is responsible for teaching her historical events.

Can I even begin to tell you how close I am to losing my marbles on this?! Let me give you something else to chew on. One of the teachers is close to retiring and the other is well into her 40′s, probably pushing 50. These are well-seasoned professionals.

I will fully admit I am no scholar. I came from small town U.S.A. and I’m pretty sure A is learning the stuff I learned in high school. I’m about as average as it gets. But good god, even I know this shit!

I would cut them some slack if perhaps the social studies teacher had misspelled serenade and the reading teacher mispronounced an important historical figure’s name. THAT I would be able to start to understand. I can’t expect my kids’ teachers to be perfect but seriously? THIS IS THEIR AREA OF EXPERTISE!

Okay, I’m done ranting. I’m sitting on my hands to keep from sending off emails informing them of their misinforming their students. It isn’t about being right (okay, maybe just a little) but more about the fact that they are teaching kids the wrong information. They are sending my daughter and her classmates (and how many before that?!) onto the next grade with brains addled with things like “screnade” and “Bone-a-party.” This is the nails on the chalkboard kind of stuff for me. The thoughts that are eating me up are “What other crappy information has she been given?”

What would you do? Would you say anything to your child’s teachers or would you just chalk it up to some serious brain farting?

 

[Side note: I live in an area known for its award-winning schools in a fairly affluent town. Who's handing out these awards...Larry, Curly, and Moe?]

[photo credit: deviantART/fallOn]


signature

7 Comments

  1. Julia Munroe Martin
    Jan 11, 2013

    What would I do? In a word: nothing. I heard the same kind of stories all through school with both my kids (and in emails from teachers, too… words misused or spelled wrong and our schools are also award winning). It was a topic of conversation at our dinner table frequently… and even when I wanted to say something, my kids wouldn’t let me. Ultimately it helped them become more careful of their own language use and more skeptical students, and I think that helped them in the long run!

    • You are right, of course. I told my daughter that just because a teacher says it’s true, doesn’t always make it so. Seeking out answers is going to be a lifelong task no matter what situation is and I told her I was proud of her for standing up for her answer in the spelling bee.

      As humans we make mistakes, lots of them, but I just hope these incidents were more the exception and not the rule. Geesh.

      I will continue to sit on my hands but I’m not gonna like it. :)

      Thanks for sharing, Julia, and helping me see the normalcy of it all.

      • Julia Munroe Martin
        Jan 13, 2013

        I never said I liked it (I didn’t) but maybe I can save you from the firefall the one time I *did* speak up… we’ll talk, Hallie :)

  2. Jessica Vealitzek
    Jan 12, 2013

    Too funny. I agree with Julia, but man, that Bonapartee would be hard to swallow. I can see “s-c” being confused with “s-e” (in saying the letters out loud, that is) but you’d think a social studies teacher would have heard the name “Bonaparte” a few times during her own education, if she paid attention. The poor teacher needs a friend to set her straight.

  3. Nina
    Jan 13, 2013

    Hallie–you are such a good story teller. I know that’s the point here, but figured I’d mention it.

    Oh gosh, what would I do??? I’d complain about it to my husband until he threatened to go in and say something. Then I’d worry he’d be too hard and make him promise not to say anything. Then I wouldn’t say anything either.

    I realize that’s not helpful.

    • That’s okay. I more or less needed to vent and you guys are my best audience. :) I know my child goes to a public school and I should be grateful but those type of mistakes really bug me. I guess this is a good life lesson for my daughter to speak up for what she knows it right. An in-class spelling bee isn’t that big of deal but if it was for a grade, you can bet I’d be all over it.

      And thanks for the nice compliment, my Nina Badina. That means a lot coming from you. xo

  4. Jolina Petersheim
    Jan 14, 2013

    That’s such a hard position to be in, Hallie. As a young mom, I don’t have any advice for you, but I commend your involvement in your child’s life (and in your other children’s as well). It’s wonderful to hear how much you support them.

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>